Plaintiff claimed that Defendant had negligently supervised  a game aboard a cruiseship, resulting in his serious injury.  Prior to trial, the court granted Hamilton, Miller & Birthisel's Motion for Summary Judgment on behalf of its cruise line client.  Several favorable rulings, including, the court granting Plaintiff's Motion to Compel plaintiff's liability expert's deposition paved the way for the favorable ruling.  Read the court's final summary judgment order.